North Jefferson News, Gardendale, AL

Opinion

October 18, 2012

Our Views: A reminder of how Alabama’s taxation methods are flawed

AN NJN EDITORIAL — A very interesting point was made last week in comments by Jefferson County Board of Education President Jennifer Parsons.

In her comments after the board selected Dr. Steven Nowlin as the system’s next superintendent, Parsons remarked about one of the reasons she felt that Nowlin was selected over Dr. Karyle Green, who is superintendent of the East Allen County Schools near Fort Wayne, Indiana. The reason: Nowlin was more familiar with Alabama’s method of funding its schools, as Indiana’s method is very different.

That may be valid, but it also serves to remind us how flawed our state’s tax system is.

Property taxes supply little revenue as they are relatively low, though Jefferson County gets more property-tax revenue than most Alabama systems, according to Nowlin. In Indiana, property taxes are considerably higher, but they are used to fund schools almost entirely, among other things. Sales taxes, which are lower (and non-existent on most groceries), are much less of a factor, and there’s no state personal income tax.

Far be it from us to say that low taxes are a bad thing, but the kind of taxes we use for school funding here are the wrong kind. Not only are they more of a burden on low-income taxpayers, but their revenue levels ebb and flow with the economy. That’s the main reason there’s so much trouble in balancing budgets these days.

Property taxes, on the other hand, vary little from year to year, and provide a more dependable source of revenue for schools to count on. And they’re more equitable across income levels, as more affluent residents pay tax on real estate, while less affluent pay on cars and such. In Indiana in particular, industry shoulders much of the property tax burden.

It’s high time that Alabama lawmakers realized that we have a horrible way of raising tax revenues for our schools, our counties and our cities.

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • Danielle Cater: What kind of banana are you?

    They say what goes in is what comes out. I’ve heard it said, “Garbage in, garbage out.” There’s a lot of truth to that statement right there.

    July 28, 2014

  • Danielle Cater: Bass fishing is just in my blood

    I was born the daughter of a fisherman. My dad was the pastor of a local church and the manager at various Jefferson County Waste Water Treatment plants, but anyone who knows him, knows he is a fisherman at heart.

    July 21, 2014

  • Danielle Cater: Making memories not that hard

    Do you spoil your kids? Do you spend enough on them? What really matters when it comes to the well-being of your children? These questions are real doozies and I think the answers vary according to the family.

    July 9, 2014

  • Danielle Cater: Graduation leads to hard decisions

    The caps and gowns are ordered, the invitations have been mailed. Checks are being written all across the country, it must be graduation time.

    May 29, 2014

  • Danielle Cater: Longevity in marriage still possible

    I have officially seen it with my own eyes. I have witnessed it with my own life. Yes, I have seen a couple who has been married 60 years and still love each other. Even more than that, they still respect each other and still genuinely love to be around each other.

    May 27, 2014

  • Danielle Cater: ‘Girl in the front’ loves her job

    I’m 33 years old. Yes, I just admitted that. The reason I throw this fact out there so freely is that I have now, officially, been working for the North Jefferson News for over 10 years. That’s right, almost 1/3 of my life has been spent behind this desk. (And yes, I’ve had the same desk all 10 years.)

    May 27, 2014

  • Danielle Cater: What memories are you leaving?

    Death hurts. It hurts when it hits close to home and it hurts when it hits the people who are closest to you.

    May 27, 2014

  • Danielle Cater: Life is precious from the beginning

    The media is all abuzz this week over the story of a woman who apparently gave birth to seven babies in the last 10 years without anyone’s knowledge, then killed her babies and stored them in boxes in her garage.

    April 24, 2014

  • Danielle Cater: Be strong in moments of weakness

    A sad scene took place on Sunday at a church in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. The founding pastor of Calvary Chapel stepped down from his position of head pastor due to “moral failing which disqualifies him from continuing his leadership role at the church.” This church is home to over 20,000 members who worship together in 10 locations across Florida.

    April 15, 2014

  • Danielle Cater: Old dogs can learn new tricks

    You’re never too old to learn something new. I’m of the opinion that you can, indeed, teach an old dog new tricks.
    So as an old dog, I’ve been trying to pick up a new trick.

    April 7, 2014